First three months - New Zealand Flag Referendum

For those non-Kiwi readers, did you know that New Zealand is currently holding a referendum on whether or not to change their flag? This has been a huge topic of debate here in Kiwiland since we arrived. Voting on the second and final referendum closes on March 24, 2016 and official results will be available March 30th. In total the flag referendum will have cost tax payers $26 million NZD. 

This is what New Zealand's current flag looks like. The four stars represent the constellation of Crux or the "Southern Cross", which is visible in the southern sky in a bright portion of the Milky Way galaxy.



The Flag Consideration Panel first selected 40 options from 10,000 submissions (see below).






















Next, the panel selected five alternative flag designs for the first referendum vote. Kiwis were asked to rank the alternative flag designs via official mail-in voter cards between November 20 - December 11, 2015. Note: the current flag was not included to be ranked in the first referendum round of voting. 
Example of the New Zealand Flag first referendum voting card.
I heard from several Kiwis that the 'Preferential Voting System" used for the first referendum was somewhat confusing. The rules stated that if one of the alternative flags got fifty percent or more of first preference votes (i.e., ranked #1) then it would be selected as the preferred alternative for the second referendum vote. Where it gets complicated is when no alternative flag received greater than fifty percent of the first preference votes. In this case the lowest ranked flag would be dropped from competition and the second highest ranked preferences from those ballots that ranked the dropped flag as first preference would be accumulated for the remaining flags until one of the flags reached greater than fifty percent. Totally not confusing, right!!?

The Silver Fern (Black, White and Blue) was confirmed as the winner. Second place was the Silver Fern (Red, White and Blue), followed by Red Peak, Silver Fern (Black and White) and Koru. The winning design and the second place design were both created by Kyle Lockwood. Personally, I preferred the black and white silver fern, but I didn't get to vote because I am not a Kiwi.

Kyle Lockwood's Silver Fern (Black, White and Blue) - The preferred alternative New Zealand Flag
The second referendum is currently taking place, and this time Kiwis must decide whether they want the silver fern or the current flag. The biggest arguments for keeping the current flag are the costs associated with changing the national flag (currently unknown) and that military veterans fought in wars under the current flag. Other folks just plain do not like change and are adamant that the flag is just fine the way it is.

There are many good arguments on why the flag should change. The best one is that New Zealand's current flag is almost indistinguishable from the Australian flag (see below). If I have learned one thing in my short time here in Kiwiland, it is that Kiwis do not like being mistaken for Aussies (it's like when Canadians are mistaken for Muricans). One woman told me that she had just recently changed her mind on the flag debate and is now supportive of the new flag. She feels strongly that New Zealand has some of the best athletes in the world and it is important that their Kiwi heritage is recognizable on the global stage. 











I think this is an amazing opportunity for New Zealand to re-brand itself. New Zealand is a very special place, with a rugged natural beauty and a distinct culture deserving to be set apart from Australia and other commonwealth countries. I think the new flag will help do that. It's also time to loose the Union Jack, an outdated symbol of British colonialism. 

As a Canadian, I can draw many comparisons between the silver fern and one of the most recognizable symbols in the world - the Canadian maple leaf, of course! Both are of botanical origin leading to obvious connotations of natural beauty and a deep connection to the natural environment. Both symbols are also memorable because they are unique. People associate the maple leaf with the polite and kind-hearted nature of Canadian people as well as the best ice hockey players. Similarly, people associate New Zealand's incredibly unique ecosystems and superior rugby skills with the silver fern. In my humble opinion, the silver fern is the right move for New Zealand's flag, which would provide an opportunity for Kiwis to join united under a fabulous new symbol of national pride, just like the maple leaf does for all Canadians. 


The Maple Leaf - An internationally recognized
symbol of Canada
The Silver Fern - A Kiwi symbol for
kickass rugby skills and natural beauty
I am so EXCITED to witness this democracy in action! I hope that New Zealand will get a new flag on March 30th!!!!














No comments:

Post a Comment